|
Table 1 - Experience Study Results F = Favorable U = Unfavorable
|
||||||
|
|
MSRS-General |
PERA-General (Basic/Coord.) |
TRA (Basic/Coord.) |
DTRFA (Old/New) |
MTRFA (Basic/Coord.) |
StPTRFA (Basic/Coord.) |
|
Interest |
||||||
|
1994-1995 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
223% F |
206% F |
215% F |
|
1995-1996 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
164% F |
215% F |
184% F |
|
1996-1997 |
256% F |
257% F |
261% F |
197% F |
209% F |
217% F |
|
1997-1998 |
262% F |
261% F |
267% F |
183% F |
181% F |
189% F |
|
1998-1999 |
134% F |
135% F |
138% F |
117% F |
150% F |
107% F |
|
1999-2000 |
124% F |
122% F |
124% F |
303% F |
153% F |
124% F |
|
Period |
192% F |
192% F |
196% F |
197% F |
185% F |
172% F |
|
Salary Increase |
||||||
|
1994-1995 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
95% F |
19% F |
141% U |
|
1995-1996 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
58% F |
113% U |
98% F |
|
1996-1997 |
117% U |
90% F |
84% F |
104% U |
126% U |
3% F |
|
1997-1998 |
86% F |
63% F |
98% F |
16% F |
122% U |
111% U |
|
1998-1999 |
97% F |
94% F |
125% U |
193% U |
122% U |
103% U |
|
1999-2000 |
151% U |
101% U |
83% F |
42% F |
131% U |
116% U |
|
Period |
114% U |
87% F |
97% F |
85% F |
123% U |
96% F |
|
Payroll Growth |
||||||
|
1994-1995 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
134% F |
105% F |
153% F |
|
1995-1996 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-70% U |
88% U |
93% U |
|
1996-1997 |
-37% U |
77% U |
70% U |
49% U |
132% F |
65% U |
|
1997-1998 |
64% U |
89% U |
76% U |
10% U |
166% F |
227% F |
|
1998-1999 |
112% F |
78% U |
96% U |
211% F |
304% F |
116% F |
|
1999-2000 |
162% F |
27% U |
90% U |
-5% U |
109% F |
109% F |
|
Period |
74% U |
68% U |
83% U |
53% U |
149% F |
127% F |
|
Retirements Under 65 |
||||||
|
1994-1995 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
76/33% F |
70/40% F |
81/58% F |
|
1995-1996 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
89/33% F |
210/117% U |
70/120% F/U |
|
1996-1997 |
158% U |
127/126% U |
81/134% F/U |
147/40% U/F |
151/175% U |
154/181% U |
|
1997-1998 |
147% U |
169/149% U |
100/149% F/U |
111/100% U/F |
210/200% U |
75/88% F |
|
1998-1999 |
135% U |
160/151% U |
67/226% F/U |
153/60% U/F |
198/223% U |
98/80% F |
|
1999-2000 |
140% U |
288/184% U |
117/210% U |
184/129% U |
189/140% U |
116/104% U |
|
Period |
145% U |
175/153% U |
88/179% F/U |
128/76% U/F |
181/164% U |
100/106% U |
|
Retirements Over 65 |
||||||
|
1994-1995 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
89%/NA U |
22/150% U/F |
78/75% U |
|
1995-1996 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
67/500% U/F |
58/157% U/F |
71/78% U |
|
1996-1997 |
98% U |
96/93% U |
100/96% F/U |
109/300% F |
29/54% U |
117/50% F/U |
|
1997-1998 |
101% F |
145/106% F |
60/93% U |
111/100% F |
50/71% U |
100/64% F/U |
|
1998-1999 |
112% F |
105/95% F/U |
67/92% U |
73/0% U |
57/77% U |
100/100% F |
|
1999-2000 |
100% F |
194/97% F/U |
133/113% F |
145/400% F |
63/50% U |
50/64% U |
|
Period |
103% F |
131/98% U/F |
93/98% U |
102/280% F |
47/81% U |
89/70% U |
|
Disabilities - Males |
||||||
|
1994-1995 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
0% F |
50% F |
0% F |
|
1995-1996 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
0% F |
50% F |
0% F |
|
1996-1997 |
135% U |
107% U |
192% U |
0% F |
0% F |
100% F |
|
1997-1998 |
132% U |
112% U |
208% U |
0% F |
100% F |
150% U |
|
1998-1999 |
114% U |
101% U |
167% U |
0% F |
0% F |
50% F |
|
1999-2000 |
108% U |
97% F |
218% U |
0% F |
0% F |
0% F |
|
Period |
122% U |
104% U |
196% U |
0% F |
33% F |
46% F |
|
Disabilities - Females |
||||||
|
1994-1995 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
0% F |
43% F |
25% F |
|
1995-1996 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
100% F |
57% F |
125% U |
|
1996-1997 |
76% F |
100% F |
311% U |
0% F |
43% F |
40% F |
|
1997-1998 |
65% F |
130% U |
330% U |
0% F |
0% F |
60% F |
|
1998-1999 |
71% F |
107% U |
290% U |
0% F |
11% F |
20% F |
|
1999-2000 |
100% F |
84% F |
370% U |
0% F |
0% F |
0% F |
|
Period |
78% F |
105% U |
326% U |
11% F |
23% F |
43% F |
|
All Terminations - Males |
||||||
|
1994-1995 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
308% F |
384% F |
219% F |
|
1995-1996 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
513% F |
600% F |
318% F |
|
1996-1997 |
262% F |
291% F |
130% F |
362% F |
371% F |
214% F |
|
1997-1998 |
183% F |
224% F |
129% F |
277% F |
272% F |
182% F |
|
1998-1999 |
158% F |
230% F |
123% F |
277% F |
350% F |
351% F |
|
1999-2000 |
161% F |
389% F |
129% F |
285% F |
373% F |
317% F |
|
Period |
190% F |
284% F |
128% F |
341% F |
399% F |
275% F |
|
All Terminations - Females |
||||||
|
1994-1995 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
392% F |
259% F |
200% F |
|
1995-1996 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
524% F |
166% F |
189% F |
|
1996-1997 |
306% F |
271% F |
132% F |
374% F |
294% F |
183% F |
|
1997-1998 |
179% F |
233% F |
138% F |
356% F |
246% F |
193% F |
|
1998-1999 |
154% F |
239% F |
136% F |
271% F |
251% F |
288% F |
|
1999-2000 |
146% F |
372% F |
132% F |
542% F |
222% F |
217% F |
|
Period |
195% F |
280% F |
134% F |
415% F |
241% F |
226% F |
|
Over 3 Yr. Terminations - Males |
||||||
|
1994-1995 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
43% U |
109% F |
38% U |
|
1995-1996 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
257% F |
215% F |
107% F |
|
1996-1997 |
335% F |
352% F |
105% F |
86% U |
167% F |
43% U |
|
1997-1998 |
209% F |
248% F |
118% F |
50% U |
150% F |
60% U |
|
1998-1999 |
189% F |
265% F |
121% F |
83% U |
224% F |
50% U |
|
1999-2000 |
170% F |
498% F |
130% F |
17% U |
205% F |
72% U |
|
Period |
230% F |
339% F |
118% F |
92% U |
181% F |
62% U |
|
Over 3 Yr. Terminations - Females |
||||||
|
1994-1995 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
38% U |
85% U |
17% U |
|
1995-1996 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
125% F |
130% F |
58% U |
|
1996-1997 |
435% F |
310% F |
112% F |
83% U |
143% F |
25% U |
|
1997-1998 |
182% F |
224% F |
134% F |
92% U |
137% F |
44% U |
|
1998-1999 |
178% F |
240% F |
142% F |
92% U |
186% F |
58% U |
|
1999-2000 |
163% F |
443% F |
141% F |
92% U |
146% F |
53% U |
|
Period |
248% F |
305% F |
132% F |
86% U |
142% F |
44% U |
|
Retiree Deaths - Males |
||||||
|
1994-1995 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
NA -- |
120% F |
139% F |
|
1995-1996 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
75% U |
176% F |
63% U |
|
1996-1997 |
92% U |
102% F |
87% U |
125% F |
91% U |
105% F |
|
1997-1998 |
99% U |
94% U |
99% U |
89% U |
104% F |
126% F |
|
1998-1999 |
106% F |
91% U |
98% U |
100% F |
111% F |
95% U |
|
1999-2000 |
93% U |
102% F |
97% U |
140% F |
96% U |
119% F |
|
Period |
99% U |
97% U |
95% U |
107% F |
115% F |
109% F |
|
Retiree Deaths - Females |
||||||
|
1994-1995 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
NA -- |
114% F |
61% U |
|
1995-1996 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
125% F |
158% F |
155% F |
|
1996-1997 |
122% F |
118% F |
114% F |
167% F |
173% F |
104% F |
|
1997-1998 |
120% F |
111% F |
115% F |
147% F |
123% F |
120% F |
|
1998-1999 |
111% F |
118% F |
129% F |
127% F |
168% F |
100% F |
|
1999-2000 |
108% F |
111% F |
132% F |
113% F |
96% U |
129% F |
|
Period |
115% F |
114% F |
122% F |
137% F |
139% F |
111% F |
|
Disabilitant Deaths - Males |
||||||
|
1994-1995 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
NA -- |
0% U |
0% U |
|
1995-1996 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
NA -- |
200% F |
200% F |
|
1996-1997 |
156% F |
140% F |
150% F |
NA -- |
NA -- |
NA -- |
|
1997-1998 |
175% F |
81% U |
86% U |
NA -- |
NA -- |
NA -- |
|
1998-1999 |
145% F |
86% U |
63% U |
NA -- |
NA -- |
NA -- |
|
1999-2000 |
105% F |
100% F |
63% U |
NA -- |
NA -- |
NA -- |
|
Period |
144% F |
102% F |
89% U |
-- -- |
100% F |
67% U |
|
Disabilitant Deaths - Females |
||||||
|
1994-1995 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
NA -- |
50% U |
0% U |
|
1995-1996 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
NA -- |
20% U |
0% U |
|
1996-1997 |
157% F |
100% F |
71% U |
NA -- |
20% U |
100% F |
|
1997-1998 |
127% F |
73% U |
113% F |
NA -- |
0% U |
0% U |
|
1998-1999 |
100% F |
100% F |
70% U |
NA -- |
0% U |
0% U |
|
1999-2000 |
111% F |
81% U |
36% U |
NA -- |
0% U |
0% U |
|
Period |
122% F |
88% U |
69% U |
0% U |
18% U |
20% U |
|
Actives Death - Males |
||||||
|
1994-1995 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
0% U |
0% U |
50% U |
|
1995-1996 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
100% F |
0% U |
200% F |
|
1996-1997 |
143% F |
111% F |
82% U |
0% U |
0% U |
150% F |
|
1997-1998 |
82% U |
134% F |
79% U |
0% U |
0% U |
0% U |
|
1998-1999 |
96% U |
121% F |
93% U |
0% U |
50% U |
100% F |
|
1999-2000 |
98% U |
75% U |
77% U |
0% U |
100% F |
50% U |
|
Period |
105% F |
110% F |
83% U |
17% U |
23% U |
86% U |
|
Actives Death - Females |
||||||
|
1994-1995 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
0% U |
38% U |
0% U |
|
1995-1996 |
-- -- |
-- -- |
-- -- |
0% U |
0% U |
33% U |
|
1996-1997 |
119% F |
112% F |
100% F |
0% U |
0% U |
0% U |
|
1997-1998 |
88% U |
104% F |
37% U |
100% F |
33% U |
67% U |
|
1998-1999 |
119% F |
126% F |
79% U |
0% U |
33% U |
100% F |
|
1999-2000 |
107% F |
99% U |
90% U |
0% U |
25% U |
167% F |
|
Period |
107% F |
111% F |
77% U |
17% U |
21% U |
65% U |